Page 286

By Jack Joseph Smith

Also Ran Against the threshold Lighting would not strick if it rained Her the finest of brown Me old and falling down There is a look among us that jars deep canyons In a moment I let youth lose its differance She was so smooth as to be the same Her skin matched mine Distant as a dream,, so much young Though she could not know How much Cherockee I am Stardust to Sun,, no love lost in the jungle Old has let me say that rough, though it is not my immigation; to the extream is not a good idea

Original Scan

Page 286

AI Interpretation

GPT

'Also Ran' binds brown skin, age, thresholds, canyons, Cherokee ancestry, stardust, jungle, and failed extremity into a meditation on difference that will not stay simple.

The last lines are the key. The poem distrusts every extreme posture it touches, including its own claims about immigration, ancestry, and desire.


Claude

A clean, refined 'Also Ran' draft that tightens the page-284 'Also Rar' material. It adds a framing first line - 'Against the threshold' - before the proverb 'Lighting would not strick if it rained' and the same age/beauty pairing, 'Her the finest of brown / Me old and falling down.' The shared look 'jars deep canyons,' and the wish for sameness sharpens: 'I let youth lose its differance,' 'so smooth as to be the same,' 'Her skin matched mine / Distant as a dream.' The ancestry claim is reordered for emphasis - 'How much Cherockee I am' - then 'Stardust to Sun,, no love lost in the jungle.' The close is the poem's truest gesture, distrusting every extreme it has touched: 'Old has let me say that rough, / though it is not my immigation; / to the extream is not a good idea' (source spellings immigation, extream, Cherockee retained).