However Careful
By Jack Joseph Smith
By Jack Joseph Smith
Original Scan
AI Interpretation
A cautionary poem about accident, blame, weather, hatred, and the fragile things a person tries to keep alive.
The repeated storm image gives the poem a ritual frame, but the real subject is how quickly life can become mangled by force and consequence.
A four-page poem framed by a quoted folk ritual - an 'Italian lady' who, when 'the Tornado comes / in Western Pennsylvania', burns 'our Palm Sunday Palm / and toss[es] it out the door'. Between the opening quotation and its near-verbatim return at the close, the poem warns that 'hatred' and an unnamed predator 'prowl[] and hunt[] / without rest', so that 'However careful' you live, you must 'be careful and true' to be 'the one / at the end of the list / who is not dead yet'.
The poem builds an apocalyptic Pennsylvania pastoral - a silo that 'first spins / Then slips through space', birds with 'prehistoric newness' of beak, the 'mangled place' where no one survives 'is viewing the clarity now' - to argue that catastrophe follows from 'a sequence of events' in which 'blame is ready made'. Against this it sets a survival ethic: keep what is 'best / in your bag of tricks', because 'hatred' picks up 'even that which sorrow / has left'. The hunting figure who 'prowls' across landscape and 'city street' fuses a literal predator (the 'crow and a cat' invoked earlier) with malice itself, and the 'eye of the needle' marks what scarcely gets through. The framing ritual is the poem's emotional anchor: an inherited, half-superstitious act of protection against forces too large to control, and the sly final line 'And you know who said it this time' folds the quoted wisdom back onto the speaker. Its four scan pages let the warnings accumulate like weather. Preserve the source phrasing throughout.